Mia's Boutique Hotel ★★★

"The property is an old motel, but they've fixed it up as best they can. Still, they are limited in what they can do, so the bathrooms are small (tiny showers; no counters by the sink). The property is designed to be used by beach goers, so there is constant sand and critters on the floor. This comes with the territory, so it's not a criticism, but if these sorts of things bother you, you likely won't like the place. Mia's has done a great job with what they have, and this place is worth staying is you want beach access or are just passing through. Keep your expectations low and you will love it."

Surf Side Hotel ★★

Sea Horse Inn and Cottages ★★

"Great stay."

Holiday Inn Express NAGS HEAD OCEANFRONT by IHG ★★★

"Very comfortable feeling"

First Colony Inn ★★★

Tar Heel Motel ★★

Sand Spur Cottages ★★

"Very comfortable and very clean"

Blue Heron Motel ★★

Colonial Inn ★★

"Our stay was fine with the exception of someone from the office knocking on our door a half hour prior to the time to check out to see if we were going to check out (which we were in the process of packing and almost done). We felt that was rude especially since I had already taken some luggage to our vehicle."