Sag Harbor Inn

My husband and I just had our second stay here and will be returning again! Helpful and kind staff-thank you Kathy and John. Beautiful harbor views, quick walk into town, the place is spotless. The continental breakfast is fresh, wonderful and plentiful. We love this place!

This property has a superb location. It is clean but is managed as a very sad place, lacking a heart. It could be superb but needs enthousiasm, openness and taste. Breakfast is minimal, wrapped in plastic bags and serve on carton plates. Where is the Long Island spirit and class ? No advise on whatsoever. Seemed nobody had ever left the premises or were not interested. If you don’t like you job, do another one !

this hotel is very strict about their deposits. if its within the 21 day window (even during the off season) they will retain the entire deposit even if you try to cancel immediately. there is really no functional way to get the money back or defer your trip to a future date. i have had similar service at Spirit Airlines.

Twilight zone employees When I greeted them they stayed silent Moldy I’d look elsewhere , with the price one may as well go To barons cove , or gurneys We told them we were arriving after midnight , but no one was there to receive us

This was the first time we stayed at the Sag Harbor Inn and it won’t be our last. The staff, accommodations and location were great. We stayed on the 2nd floor with a harbor view which was perfect. The room was immaculate and well appointed. The restaurants, shops and marina are all within walking distance. Highly recommend,

This is not a resort nor fancy hotel; it's a clean and comfortable place to stay. We would stay here again. Our room was quite spacious with a queen bed, sofa, desk, and two sinks. There were plenty of drawers and hangers too. They provided Beekman 1802 soaps, moisturizer, shampoo (color-safe) and conditioner. They even had makeup removal packets. Our room also had a very quiet refrigerator. I especially appreciated the numerous USB and electric outlets. The property is very well maintained; while not new (renovated in 2016), everything seemed fresh and clean. The hotel is just a 9 minute walk from the Jitney stop and convenient to everything in town. A simple breakfast was included with the room, consisting of cereals, yogurt, some fruit, tea, coffee and bread (slices, bagels, and English muffins). There's a nice pool, but it's not heated. Our backdoor opened to a terrace facing the pool. We did not not have a private terrace. All the rooms on the first floor facing the pool open to the same area without dividers. Room for improvement: The TV is small on a big wall! There are no robes nor slippers. We could hear people talking in the hall. We had a first floor room and in the mornings noticed people walking in the room overhead. There's just one flat sheet under the blanket (rather than an add'l one on top of the blanket). They change the sheets regularly, but the blanket?

This is a great little inn. It’s not super fancy, but it offers very comfortable beds. clean rooms, pool, super location and a nice continental breakfast. I really enjoyed my coffee each morning sitting outside on the covered patio with a view of the marina. All of these combine to make an enjoyable stay.

Chose this hotel because of closeness to harbor. Other inn next door has pool in front so rooms overlook pool and are set back. The hotel was very neat and well kept. Our room was room 215 and had a queen bed. Had a bathtub/shower combo..only thing that could have been better was a grab bar in shower.The hotel was quiet, it was off season. I requested a room away from elevator and ice machine, which I am glad I did because there are rooms directly opposite the elevator on each floor. The continental breakfast included yogurt, cereal, bagels, toast and fresh fruit. You make your own coffee with Kuerig, which was nice, as I find the carafes some hotels use dont keep coffee hot. Plenty of reading material in lobby. Great relaxing stay.

Husband and I took our two young kids on an a mini vacation to Sag Harbor. We stayed one night and had the best time. The hotel is simple but very clean! I would say this hotel is far cleaner than other Marriott hotels I’ve stayed at. We checked in at 2pm with no issues and our room was ready. There was coffee, tea, and hot chocolate available. Our first floor Harborview two beds room was perfect. Double sinks were a plus for us. The shower pressure was very good. We loved being able to walk outside to grassy area in front of hotel. My kids were even able to cheer runners doing a 5K. The breakfast was included and good for my family. Coffee and juice were available. Food wise there was toast, bagels, English muffins, yogurts and cereal. Overall we were pleased with the hotel and would return and recommend to others!