Old Town Inn

This was our first time on the island and our first experience staying at an inn and Neal and his girls went above and beyond to make us feel at home We traveled to the island for a family wedding and a large group of us stayed at old town inn we loved it so much we extended our stay! Breakfast was made fresh every morning and homemade muffins and juice for snacks the inn is super clean and updated we loved sitting by the fire in the cozy sitting room playing games and hanging out we will definitely return to the inn for our next family vacation

Wow, this place is truly a gem! So glad I stumbled upon it. While it's not exactly in town, it has so many other benefits. To start, the rooms are large and beautifully decorated/newly renovated. We loved the contemporary/beach decor. Thankfully, it's NOT a stuffy Victorian B & B. We were so comfortable there from the start. The common spaces were bright, tasteful and spacious. We loved the outdoor fire pit (there are actually 2), gazebo, the corn hole games, delicious breakfasts out on the deck overlooking the expansive yard, stargazing from the Adirondack chairs, the list goes on and on. Neal was such a wonderful host, too! Ok, so the location...it's much more quiet than it would be staying in town. There's ample parking, and many of the guests bring their cars. We brought our bicycles instead, and loved that we embarked on this super fun adventure. We're in our late 50's and are pretty good cyclists, so it was a perfect choice. Contrary to popular belief, Block Island isn't flat, so if you're thinking of tooling around on a rental bike, maybe you should rethink that plan. However, it's only about mile walk to town and there are plenty of cabs (Ubers, maybe?) to take you to wherever you want to go. In fact, even though we had our bikes, we walked to town for dinner each night (didn't want to drink and pedal). I truly hope that we'll return to Block Island again. We had never been there, and it was absolutely lovely. We would definitely plan to stay at the Old Town Inn again!

We would come back here in a heartbeat. Friendly and welcoming owners, beautiful property with a yard, delicious breakfast, comfortable and clean rooms with interesting artwork, reasonable rates… a perfect place to stay in every way!

We stayed here for a very fun girls’ weekend. The Inn is in a lovely historic building but the accommodations were bright (lots of windows), spacious, and very modern! My room (#10) had lovely views from every window—even the bathroom! The property is beautiful and common areas are roomy and comfortable. The Inn’s location is terrific—close to everything but also peaceful. We hiked, saw seals, went into town, drank and ate to excess, laughed a lot, and had a ball! I hope to be back!

A wonderful place. I stayed for a few day's, I was on island for a wedding. Great staff, great owner and a great location. Everything is well thought out and you truly feel welcomed and at home the minute you walk in the door. Great location, minutes to everything

Neal’s place is absolutely beautiful! It has such a tranquil vibe, with tasteful decor. It is impeccably clean and welcoming. Beds and linens were extremely comfortable, and breakfast in the morning was such a nice touch. The outdoor seating and lounging areas were plentiful, and we had so much privacy during the entirety of our stay. The staff were very professional and kind. Coffee was available all day, and on some of the days they had a lemonade punch available. There were two small fridges with small freezers for guests to use, in common areas. We loved this quiet location-away from the hustle and bustle of the busier areas. We would love to return.