Fenway Hotel, Autograph Collection

The photos of the suite on the booking platform were misleading. Instead of fresh, bright and refurbished look, we got dark and old rooms (except for the bathroom, this was really like depicted). All my special request were „not received“. So I ended up on ground floor with direct view to the sunbeds and sofas of the pool. Cancelled my 2nd night there.

The concept is great, with an intimate and authentic decor. BUT: it's extremely overpriced. Drinks are $20.00 each (which you're NOT told until you get the check), 2 drink minimum and selection is limited. The three of us ordered 6 different drinks and none of them were very good; too weak or too strong, some not prepared the way we asked. To top it off there's NO food available except for a small bowl of pretzels. With tax and tips to bartender/ server/ parking valet, the total (including $36 reservation fee) came to $264. I'm sure corporate wants a profit from day one, but that's a fatal error in this case. They should have done this right by making it a "business-builder" for the brand; wow us with amazing drinks, throw in an appetizer or dessert and do it all in a way that would cause one to want to return and enjoy the hotel's restaurants and lodging. I've patronized the Hi-Fi Rooftop Bar many times, but I doubt I'll ever return after this disappointing "experience."

It's interesting how some people love it and others not so much.... we thouroghly enjoyed our stay at the Fenway. Our room was perfect, cocktails on the rooftop watching the sunset was great, one can also order food on the rooftop bar. We had breakfast in the restaurant and were both quite satisfied with service and quality. All the staff we interacted with were friendly and accomodating. The only negatives I would share: for only an 80 room hotel, there are a lot of hallways, going every which way, one needs to pay attention where your room is located and there is only one elevator so at times there is a wait to go up or down. The building has only been a hotel for about 5 years and has a very interesting past. We inquired at the front desk about the history and were given a printout about the background of the building. Everything added up to a nice couple of days. Would stay there again if in Dunedin.

What a great place to watch the sunset! The welcome cocktail was a nice touch, and they did a great job of recognizing our Marriott status at check-in. Our room was really comfortable and had a great view. The rooftop bar has a nice cocktail menu and some great local beers. Dunedin is awesome, and this is the perfect place to explore it from.

First time visiting Dunedin - what a wonderful place to stay! Close to downtown and restaurants. Only a few minutes to Clearwater as well. Rooms very nice and comes with complimentary snacks and goodies for the guests. Also - upon arrival you get a free beverage! Only one restaurant at this hotel - wish they had more choices but with the close proximity to town it’s something we did not mind. Valet service also provided. Front desk staff very welcoming as well. Enjoy this property!

The Fenway is a lovely old building dating from the 1920’s. The best part of our visit was the staff. All were very friendly and accommodating. On our first night, we had Champagne and charcuterie on the front lawn for the sunset and it was lovely. We had a drink at the rooftop bar, a very casual venue and a great place to watch the sunset. The drink prices were about what you would expect from an upscale hotel. We had dinner in the Hew Parlor and Chophouse. The food and service was excellent! Now for the not so great things: our room was well appointed, but very small, which maybe I should have expected from a 1920’s building. We had a water view room, but it was on the ground floor, so the view was limited. If you should decide to pay extra for a water view, I recommend getting a room on the 2nd or 3rd floors. Surprisingly, there is no bell service, so we had to wrestle our luggage on our own. Also, no room service and no newspapers. Our room didn’t have an ice bucket and when one was delivered, it had no lid. The Fenway is a popular venue for weddings. When we were there the small lobby and lobby bar were jammed with celebrants. Lots of pluses, but also lots of minuses for an expensive hotel.

Staff is so great!! LILY in restaurant is so friendly and Knowledgeable. Marie and Cora were Good as well TERRY on roof too bar is the best!!! The rooms were super clean - we got a suite- but king bed in single room is ok As well. View of water is pretty and 1st Is the safety. We felt safe staying here Will come again soon. ❤️

I have always wanted to stay at the Fenway Hotel and finally managed to do it. My husband and I stayed 2 nights, we are in our 60's. I booked a King room and was upgraded to a suite that overlooked the pool. It was just beautiful! Very quiet room and the bed was comfy. I am a picky traveler that stays at a lot of hotels and must have quiet and a comfy bed, so they get an A+. The staff was helpful and very friendly making sure anything we needed was attended to. The rooftop bar was amazing and drinks were great. The only complaint I had was trying to ride one of the bikes. The process was frustrating but doable. Otherwise, it's a great hotel in a great location. We were able to walk to restaurants and the waterfront.

Weekend getaway . Upon arrival there was a wedding so couldn’t park on entrance so parked in the back and carried luggage to entrance . Upon check in they told us pool and garden was closed due to private event . Pool was very small for 83 rooms with 4 umbrellas and 15 beds . No bar . Nobody to serve at bar in lobby . Rooftop bar is nicely located . Drinks are sportsbar quality . Rooms are small but nice . View was the noisy A/C units . Location is great at 10 min walk from downtown and access the Gulf . With better management could be a great stay . Definitely not worth the 1195$ for 2 nights , breakfast and parking not included